Please read through the excerpt..
To: My Fellow Filipinos and Artists
Many of us in the artists community were shocked and appalled that Carlo J. Caparas was named National Artist for Visual Arts and Film on July 2009. Although we recognize the work and accomplishments of Caparas within the comic book industry as well as television and film, we strongly believe that his body of work does not live up to the tradition of excellence the title of National Artist entails.
It is appalling to us that someone who has made a living exploiting the lowest common denominator in films such as “The Cecilia Masagca Story: Antipolo Massacre (Jesus Save Us!) “, “The Untold Story: Vizconde Massacre 2 – God Have Mercy on Us “, “Lipa Arandia Massacre (Lord Deliver Us from Evil)”, and “The Marita Gonzaga Rape-Slay: In God We Trust! ” shall now be placed in the same league as Manuel Conde and Lino Brocka, the greatest filmmakers in the Philippines responsible for our greatest movies as “Ghengis Khan” and “Maynila: Sa Mga Kuko ng Liwanag” respectively.
However, if one is looking for an objective reason for this protest, it would be this:
It is clear that “Visual Arts” and “Film” are two different categories. Therefore, “Visual Arts” refer to Caparas’ work in comics. Caparas is a writer. He has never illustrated any of his comics stories, least of all his most popular ones. Panday and Pieta? They were illustrated by Steve Gan. Bakekang? It was illustrated by Mar Santana. Kroko? Illustrated by Hal Santiago. Totoy Bato? Illustrated by Tor Infante.
In the guidelines for selection of National Artist for Visual Artists, the category clearly covers:
“Visual Arts – painting, sculpture, printmaking, photography, installation art, mixed media works, illustration, graphic arts, performance art and/or imaging;”
How can someone who is not an illustrator, therefore *NOT* a visual artist ever be named National Artist for Visual Arts? If Carlo should ever be given this title, the title should be shared with all the artists he collaborated with, for that is the nature of comics. It is a collaborative medium as Carlo himself points out many times during his talks.
If not, then this title should be removed, as it is not factually descriptive of who he is. In short, Carlo J. Caparas is NOT qualified to be National Artist. The guidelines unarguably points this fact out.
Our objection and resolve are strengthened by news that have recently come to light that Carlo J. Caparas did not go through the rigorous selection and assesment process of the National Artists voting board. Carlo J. Caparas is a SNAG, or “Singit National Artist ni Gloria”. It is through this Presidential insertion process that a person who is not qualified to be National Artist manages to be one.
As Philippine artists and concerned citizens who feel that our artistic legacy as a nation is compromised by these events, we strongly and vehemently put forward this protest.
Sincerely,
The Undersigned
Please click on the link below to vote. Thanks.
probinsyanachronicles.wordpress.com 
I agree…
this is a time of fakes: fake products, fake money, fake jobs, fake recruiters, fake politicians who disguised themselves as kabayans or champions of the poor, etc. etc…..now comes a fake national artist?.. but i say nothing beats a fake president!!!
… no wonder we are a nation of fakes!!!!
just want to show some appretiation, i visit every now and again to stay with the current news.
thank you for taking time in reading my posts.. i’ll try to update the posts as much as i can now.. enjoy
BASAHIN NYO ITO:
LETTER TO THE EDITOR
The Arrogance of Protesting National Artists
A surprise histrionic attack was launched on the selection of the 2009 National Artists proclaimed by President Gloria Macapagal Arroyo. When the Cultural Center of the Philippines finds it convenient, its leadership appeals not to inject politics into the arts as it has become the object of protests by victims of the martial law regime of Marcos. The CCP is now in a controversy for its recognition or restoration of a discredited conjugal dictatorship. Yet obviously, the CCP after fueling the national artist brouhaha, surprisingly, has directed a political assault on the President with her duty and authority of giving a State Award. At the Congressional hearing, the Minutes of the meeting of the NCCA Board signed by some of protesting CCP officials and National Artists like Rio Almario and Eddie Romero and son of National Artist, Felipe De Leon were unfolded. The November 6 and December 4, 1997 discussion respectively states as follows:
“c. The two Boards concluded that it is within the President’s prerogative to create new categories as well as declare awardees without the benefit of passing through formal selection process.” (November 6, 2007; NCCA Minutes of the Regular Commission Meeting, page 3)
And
“It was emphasized that the NCCA Commissioners and the CCP Trustees acknowledge the authority and prerogative of the President of the Philippines to create National Artist Categories, to disapprove recommendations made to him by the NCCA and CCP, or to designate National Artists on his own initiative.” (last paragraph, page 2; December 4, 1997; NCCA Minutes of the Regular Commission Meeting)
Clearly, from these meetings since 1997, there was a consensus and unanimity after resolving the rancor against President Fidel Ramos choice of Carlos Quirino for a new category of historical literature. To quote Shakespeare “it was all sound and fury signifying nothing” since in the end, CCP-NCCA Joint Board acknowledged Presidential authority and prerogative to proclaim National Artists. Their function is limited to advise. The entire melodrama of protests for 2009 was maliciously conjured up as a media magnet of hitting the President and unleashing a smear and vilification campaign against the persona of the 2009 National Artists. Unfortunately, whoever IS the Machiavellian gang who started the vicious trial by publicity unfairly misled a whole community and paved a highway of conflict where there should be none.
The prevailing rule is Executive Order No. 236 which rationalized all government awards into an Honors Code creating an Honors Committee to assist the President which has the capacity to liaise with appropriate government agencies such as the CCP and NCCA for preliminary recommendation and selection as well as receive other nominations and consult with expert resource persons in the field to provide additional advise for the President’s judgment. To make sure that there is no variance or difference of interpretation of the CCP-NCCA role, Executive Order 435 amending Section 5 of the Honors Code underscored its function as advisory and not mandatory.
We congratulate the President for her discernment in choosing Bobby Mañosa, who pioneered a distinctive fILIPINO architecture through use of indigenous materials, Pitoy Moreno dubbed Asia’s fashion czar, Carlo Caparas, the Comics King for his voluminous work of comics stories that have been transformed into TV and film as part of his efforts to revive the comics industry: as well as giving a long overdue recognition to Cecile Guidote-Alvarez, the youngest Filipina to have received a Ramon Magsaysay Outstanding Asian Award as PETA Founder linking Philippine theatre to the international arena since 1972and hailed as the 1st UNESCO Artist for Peace Awardee from our country IN 2003. Even in exile she merited the UN Human Rights Day Award for Theatrical innovation and provided cultural services to Filipinos abroad.
Where is the abuse? Their credentials are solid. If they were daughters or brothers or political allies without qualifications, only then can you raise the issue of the President’s abuse of discretion. When the protestors including the children of Marcos berated her as an over rated artist raised the issue against certain prohibitions on Cecile Guidote-Alvarez, the Office of the Solicitor General analyzed that it is not prescribed by the internal rule of CCP-NCCA they cited as they are deemed unrelated or impertinent to her status. She was not nominated in the CCP-NCCA process where she was involved as the head of the coordinating secretariat. She also did not participate in the Honors Committee deliberation where she was nominated by Ramon Magsaysay Awardee and Congressional Medal of Merit Awardee. Fr. James B. Rueter, S.J., National Artist, Dr. Alejandro R. Roces and Sen. Edgardo Angara among others.
Corollarily, the President’s proclamation of Alvarez is not unprecedented. The late Carlos P. Romulo was declared National Artist during his incumbency as Secretary of Foreign Affairs by President Marcos. Until Congress comes up with an amendment or create a new law to govern the selection of National Artists, we must respect the rule of law. I attended the Congressional Hearing presided by Rep. Del De Guzman providing a chance for Dialogue instead of one sided accusations. We advise people to look at the facts rather than adhere to a culture of gossip and vendetta. There are some protesters who may have some axe to grind against some of the proclaimed National Artists. There are also those who relish the protest venue for their party list membership in aid of election.
It would be good for Congress to look into the parameters of a parallel National Medal of Arts in the US where the President is given the freehand as head of state to select from among the names submitted by the National Council of Arts and the National Endowment of the Arts as well as include those of his own initiative as long as it does not exceed a list of 12 artists annually.
What is amazing is the arrogance and lack of delicadeza of some national artists claiming monopoly of artistic expertise, excellence and exceptional body of works. We lay our trust on the SC for their decision on the legalities of the proclamation. When the CCP board wanted to arrogate upon itself the selection of trustees and whipped out a storm amongst themselves, the Supreme Court rendered its judgment on the pre-eminence of presidential prerogative. Here we go again, there is a saying: Those who do not learn from their past are condemned to relive it.
Commissioner Abdulrahman
Komisyon sa Wikang Filipino (KWF)
well to one on its own.. it doesnt really matter now since Arroyo doesnt acknowledge the existence of those artists that are rightfully deserving for this stand. … sirang sira na sia,.. she just made a stir out of this para iba ang mapagusapan at hindi ang totoong issue na gaya ng abuse of power.
i wont even wonder if the sender of this letter is Carlo Caparas himself… (vomit)